The Secret Inquisition

The Untold Story of Mussolini, the Vatican, and Fascist Italy’s War on the Jews

"With astonishing archival tenacity and immense narrative power, David Kertzer ventures deep into the bureaucratic labyrinth that determined, in the wake of Fascist Italy’s racial laws, who was a Jew and who was not. The stories he has uncovered have few saints, many sinners, and a substantial number of villains. At the book’s center are desperate people who find themselves living in a Kafka-like nightmare from which they cannot awaken. Kertzer’s blend of irony, compassion, and unshakable commitment to the truth brilliantly illuminates an Italy that has until now been hidden away."
—Stephen Greenblatt, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of The Swerve and John Cogan University Professor of the Humanities, Harvard University 

"David Kertzer is the master. Another utterly gripping account of pain, courage and mendacity, ripe for our times."
—Philippe Sands, Professor of Law, University of London, and author of East West Street

Publisher: Random House

Published: January 19, 2027

ISBN: 9780593978719

Pages: 368

Pre-order Today At

Full summary

Eager to solidify his alliance with Hitler, Benito Mussolini shocked Italy and the world in 1938 by announcing a campaign against the country’s small but ancient Jewish minority.  Jews were cast as a foreign, noxious race, against whom draconian measures had to be taken.  The new “racial laws” threw Jewish children and teachers out of the country’s schools and dismissed Jews from their jobs in much of the economy.  While historians have devoted much attention to these dramatic events, The Secret Inquisition brings to light a major feature of that campaign that, surprisingly, has until now remained unknown.  Facing immiseration and social isolation, thousands of those categorized as members of the “Jewish race” applied to the government office charged with overseeing the racial laws to have their race changed to “Aryan.”  While in theory the distinction between members of the “Jewish race” and those of the majority “Aryan race” was based on biology, in fact proof of racial identity was not based on any physical characteristic but rather on religious records.  The result were efforts by thousands of those categorized as Jews to get baptized, with cooperative Catholic priests backdating their baptisms.  Rooted in research done in Italian and Vatican archives on thousands of previously unexamined cases, the book, by Pulitzer Prize-winning author David Kertzer, is written for a broad audience. It focuses on eleven dramatic cases, including, among others, Nobel Prize-winning physicist Enrico Fermi and his Jewish wife; Mussolini's longtime Jewish lover, Margherita Sarfatti; Italy's most popular novelist of the time (and secret Fascist spy), Dino Segre; and the pope’s dentist, who claims, as many others conveniently do, that his true father was not the Jewish man married to his Jewish mother, but his mother’s secret Catholic lover. Filled with shocking personal details and tear-soaked pleas to Mussolini and his semiliterate wife, The Secret Inquisition offers insight into problems of antisemitism, fascism, persecution of minorities, and the degradation that comes with living under dictatorships, lessons all too relevant to the world today.

International Editions (available soon)

  • British edition:  Oxford University Press

  • Italian edition:  Garzanti

  • Russian edition:  Azbooka